العربية
القائمة

Train or Hire Calculator

Should You Train This Employee or Hire Someone Better?

Compare training your current employee with replacing them, using the training cost, the future wage, the candidate you actually have, availability, job demands and time.

No revenue is invented when the business effect cannot be reliably valued.

Example scenario

Sample values. Editing any field switches this page to your own scenario.

Why Are You Considering a Change?

Decision Check

Training only changes Skill. It does not add headcount, availability or remove job demands.

Continue to the comparison

What Result Do You Need?

Training method

Check whether this target matters

This target reaches the entered goal.

180 output / batch

Check employee ROI

Analysis horizon

Option A — Keep & Train

Current employee · Factory Worker

Skill
60 → 80
Hourly wage
‏24.50 US$
Future wage
‏29.40 US$
Training cost
‏422.40 US$
Upfront cost
‏422.40 US$
Future payroll
‏14,112.00 US$
Known total
‏14,534.40 US$
Time to target
6 days
Availability
Fits the required hours
Job demands
Compatible right now
Role fit
Correct role

Calculated from the training formula

During training

Additional demands can appear as Skill increases.

Option B — Replace

Do you have a candidate?

Availability
Job demands
Role fit
Recruitment cost

During the transition

Until the replacement starts
Skill
60 → 85
Future wage
‏30.00 US$
Upfront cost
‏500.00 US$
Future payroll
‏14,400.00 US$
Known total
‏14,900.00 US$
Time to target
Available now
Availability
Cannot work the required hours
Job demands
Compatible right now

Visible demands fit your scenario now. Future demands are not assumed.

Compare Both Options

CompareOption A — Keep & TrainOption B — Replace
Skill target60 → 8060 → 85
Known cost‏14,534.40 US$‏14,900.00 US$
Time6 daysAvailable now
Availability fitFits the required hoursCannot work the required hours
Demand fitCompatible right nowCompatible right now
Future demandsUnknownUnknown
CostCompleteComplete

Uncertainty

Training reaches the target and preserves the required fit

Training reaches the operational goal and keeps the current availability and demand situation.

Key Differences

Training costs less over the entered horizon. ‏365.60 US$

  • Current employee: Fits the required hours
  • Replace: Cannot work the required hours
  • Job demands: Compatible right now

No overall winner is assumed.

What Is Not Included?

  • Unknown future demands
  • Business revenue, unless you supply it

Unknown is never treated as zero.

Third Route: Natural Growth

If the employee already fits the role and you are not in a hurry, check whether natural skill growth is relevant before paying for training or replacing them.

Check natural growth

How to Choose Between Training and Replacing an Employee

Training only changes Skill. It does not add headcount, availability or remove job demands.

Unknown is never treated as zero.

Train or Replace Questions

Should I train this employee or replace them?

It depends on whether training can reach the target and whether a real candidate fits the work. This page shows both sides instead of naming a winner.

Why is no best option shown?

Because the cheaper side is not always the side that solves the problem.

Does a higher Skill always mean a cheaper employee?

No. Paid training also raises the wage, so a trained employee can cost more over time than a direct hire.

Will the candidate keep exactly these demands?

Only the demands visible now are compared, and future demands are never assumed.

What is not included?

Unknown is never treated as zero.